Roth Conversion Strategy: 5 Ways Conversions Pay Off, Before and After
Five Roth conversion strategies, each shown before and after in a real simulation. One $1.2M IRA saver cut lifetime federal tax from $467,000 to $251,000.
“Why would I pay tax on my IRA before I have to?” It is the most common objection to a Roth conversion, and it sounds reasonable. However, the money in a traditional IRA will be taxed eventually. The real question is at what rate, and in which years. A Roth conversion strategy is simply how you choose those years instead of letting required minimum distributions choose them for you.
To show what that choice can be worth, we ran one household through a retirement simulation twice: once with no conversions and once with an optimized conversion plan. This article walks through the five strategies behind the difference, each with its own before-and-after result.
What is a Roth conversion?
A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA (or an eligible workplace plan) into a Roth IRA. The pre-tax amount you convert is added to your taxable income for that year. After that, the money grows tax-free and qualified withdrawals are tax-free.
5 Roth conversion strategies at a glance
- Convert in your low-tax years: the “tax valley” between retiring and the start of Social Security and RMDs.
- Shrink your required minimum distributions before they start.
- Pay the conversion tax from a taxable brokerage account, not from the IRA.
- Cut the tax on your Social Security benefits.
- Keep Medicare IRMAA surcharges small.
These are not five separate plans. A good conversion plan does all five at once, and each strategy below is one view of the same before-and-after simulation.
How the before-and-after simulation works
We ran one household through our simulation twice. The “before” run makes no conversions. The “after” run uses the conversion schedule the optimizer found to leave the most after-tax money at the end of the plan.
| You | 62, single, retired; plan runs to age 92 |
|---|---|
| Accounts |
|
| Spending | $70,000 a year |
| Social Security | $40,000 a year, claimed at 70 |
| Tax law | 2025 federal law held constant, so every figure reads as today’s dollars |
| Returns and state tax | 5% a year on every account; flat 5% state income tax |
| Paying for things | Spending and conversion tax come from the taxable account first, then Roth, then the IRA |
With conversions, your lifetime federal income tax fell from $467,000 to $251,000. The five strategies below show where that difference came from.
Strategy 1: Convert in your low-tax years
For many retirees, income drops sharply after the last paycheck and then climbs again once Social Security and RMDs arrive. That gap is the retirement tax valley, and it is usually the cheapest time to pay tax on IRA money.
In the “before” run, you live on your taxable savings first. Your adjusted gross income (AGI) is about $27,000 a year from 62 to 65 and your federal income tax is $0. Later, RMDs push your AGI to $103,000 at 75 and $180,000 at 92.
In the “after” run, the optimizer fills those empty early years with Roth conversions. It converts $160,000 at 62, about $100,000 a year from 63 to 67, and smaller amounts after that. In this way, IRA money is taxed in years when you have little other income, instead of on top of large RMDs later.
Read the full guide to timing conversions in the retirement tax valley.
Strategy 2: Shrink your RMDs before they start
Required minimum distributions start at 73 or 75, depending on your birth year, and are a growing percentage of your traditional IRA balance each year. Every dollar you convert before then is a dollar that never has to come out on the IRS’s schedule. Roth IRAs have no RMDs during the owner’s lifetime.
| Your RMDs | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| First RMD (age 75) | $69,000 | $21,000 |
| Largest RMD | $128,000 | $40,000 |
| Lifetime RMDs | $1.78M | $553,000 |
See how to reduce RMDs with Roth conversions, including what happens with a $2.2M IRA.
Strategy 3: Pay the conversion tax from your taxable account
Where the tax money comes from matters almost as much as how much you convert. If you pay the tax from a brokerage account, the full conversion lands in the Roth, and your taxed-every-year account gets smaller. It works like a Roth contribution with no annual limit.
How much that is worth depends on a few things:
- Yield: interest and dividends are taxed every year, so a bond-heavy or high-dividend account costs more in yearly tax than a low-yield stock index fund.
- Your tax rate on that income: interest is taxed as ordinary income, qualified dividends at 0%, 15%, or 20%, and the 3.8% net investment income tax applies once your modified AGI is above $200,000 (single).
- Built-in gains: selling shares with a low cost basis to raise the cash adds capital gains tax to the cost of each conversion.
- Time: if the account is going to pay your living costs in the next few years anyway, paying the tax from it mostly changes the timing. If it would otherwise grow for decades, the benefit is larger.
In our example, your $300,000 brokerage account pays for most of your first years of retirement in both runs, so this strategy plays a smaller role than it would with a larger account. Even so, your lifetime taxable dividends and interest fall from $147,000 to $14,000. Without conversions, the RMDs you do not need get reinvested in a taxable account, and the income on them grows every year.
Read how to pay taxes on a Roth conversion, and why the smaller account can be worth more.
Strategy 4: Cut the tax on your Social Security
Up to 85% of your Social Security benefit can be taxable, depending on your other income. RMDs are often what pushes retirees to that maximum.
In the “before” run, 85% of your benefit is taxable every year from 75 to 92. In the “after” run, your smaller RMDs leave 27% to 66% of it taxable over those years. Over your lifetime, taxable Social Security falls from $763,000 to $431,000.
The plan does not escape the “tax torpedo,” the income range where each extra dollar also makes more of your benefit taxable. Instead, it keeps you at the low end of that range, where the extra tax is smallest. How to cut Social Security taxes with Roth conversions.
Strategy 5: Keep Medicare IRMAA surcharges small
Medicare adds an income-related monthly adjustment amount (IRMAA) to Part B and Part D premiums when your modified AGI from two years earlier is above a threshold.
In the “before” run, your growing RMDs trigger a surcharge every year from 78 to 92, and it gets larger as your income climbs into higher tiers. In the “after” run, you pay the smallest surcharge from 65 to 69 and none after that. The optimizer accepted a few small, planned surcharges to remove many larger ones later.
| Your IRMAA surcharges | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Years with a surcharge | 15 (ages 78–92) | 5 (ages 65–69) |
| Largest yearly surcharge | $4,235 | $1,053 |
| Lifetime surcharges | $30,100 | $5,300 |
How to avoid IRMAA surcharges with Roth conversions.
Other benefits of a Roth conversion
- Heirs: qualified withdrawals from an inherited Roth IRA are generally tax-free, though most heirs must empty the account within 10 years. In our simulation, the after-tax amount left to heirs in a 32% bracket rose from $1.84 million to $2.18 million.
- Flexibility: qualified Roth withdrawals are not counted in AGI, so a large expense later in life (a car, a roof, care costs) does not raise your tax bracket, Social Security taxation, or Medicare premiums.
- Tax diversification: having both pre-tax and Roth money lets you choose where each year’s spending comes from.
Why one rule of thumb is not a strategy
Popular conversion rules, such as “fill the 12% bracket every year,” can help. However, in our simulation none of them matched a plan that changed size as your situation changed.
| Approach (same household) | Gain vs no conversions |
|---|---|
| Optimized plan | +$311,000 |
| Stay under the first IRMAA tier every year | +$229,000 |
| Fill the 12% bracket every year | +$204,000 |
| Fill the 22% bracket every year | +$190,000 |
Gain is measured as ending after-tax value, with the remaining traditional IRA reduced by 24% federal and 5% state tax.
The optimized plan converted the most at 62, before the income Medicare looks back on starts to count. It then eased off as IRMAA tiers and Social Security came into play, and it stopped once RMDs began. It never converted everything in one year.
When a Roth conversion may not pay off
Conversions are not right for everyone. They may help less, or not at all, if:
- You would have to pay the tax from the IRA itself, especially before 59½, when the withheld amount can also face a 10% penalty.
- You expect a much lower tax rate later, for example because of large deductible long-term care costs.
- You are buying health insurance through the ACA marketplace before 65. Conversions raise the income used for premium tax credits, and since the enhanced credits expired after 2025, crossing 400% of the federal poverty level can cost the entire credit.
- You need the converted money within five years.
- You plan to move from a high-tax state to one with no income tax.
FAQ
What is the best Roth conversion strategy?
There is no single best amount. The strategies that worked in our simulation were to convert in low-income years, size each year’s conversion to a real threshold (a bracket top or IRMAA tier), pay the tax from taxable savings, and finish most conversions before Social Security and RMDs begin.
Is a Roth conversion worth it at 60?
It can be, especially if you have retired and have several years before Social Security and RMDs. Those years are often your lowest-tax years. Whether it is worth it depends on your tax rate now versus later and how you will pay the tax.
Do I have to pay the tax from outside money?
No, but it usually helps. Paying from the IRA means less money reaches the Roth, and if you are under 59½ the amount used for tax may also face a 10% penalty.
Can I undo a Roth conversion?
No. Conversions made after 2017 cannot be recharacterized, so it pays to decide late in the year, once you know your income.
How much should I convert each year?
Enough to use up a low tax bracket or reach just under a meaningful threshold, such as the top of the 12% or 22% bracket or an IRMAA tier. In our simulation the right target changed from year to year.
Conclusion
A Roth conversion strategy is a way of choosing your tax rate instead of letting RMDs choose it for you. In our simulation, the same household paid $216,000 less in lifetime federal income tax, had much smaller RMDs, paid less tax on Social Security, and paid far fewer Medicare surcharges.
Whether conversions fit your plan depends on your brackets now and later, how you can pay the tax, your health coverage before 65, and what you want to leave behind. Use the strategy guides above to go deeper.
This article is for educational purposes and is not personalized tax or investment advice. Tax rules change; figures reflect 2025–2027 federal law as noted. Simulation results are illustrative and depend on the assumptions listed above.