How to Cut Social Security Taxes With Roth Conversions (and Tame the Tax Torpedo)
Up to 85% of Social Security can be taxed. In our before-and-after simulation, Roth conversions cut lifetime taxable benefits by $332,000.
Up to 85% of your Social Security benefit can be taxable, and the trigger is your other income. For many retirees, that other income is mostly required minimum distributions (RMDs) from a traditional IRA. Shrinking those RMDs with Roth conversions is one of the most direct ways to reduce taxes on Social Security. It also tames the tax torpedo: the income range where each extra dollar makes more of your benefit taxable.
To show how much this can change, we ran one retiree through our simulation twice: once with no conversions and once with an optimized conversion plan.
This article explains how benefits are taxed, what the tax torpedo is, and how a conversion plan changed both for you.
How Social Security is taxed
The share of your benefit that is taxable depends on your provisional income:
Provisional income = your adjusted gross income (AGI) without Social Security + tax-exempt interest + half of your Social Security benefit
For a single filer, the thresholds are:
| Provisional income | Share of benefits that can be taxable |
|---|---|
| Under $25,000 | 0% |
| $25,000 to $34,000 | Up to 50% |
| Over $34,000 | Up to 85% |
No more than 85% of your benefit is ever taxable. IRS Publication 915 has the full worksheet.
These thresholds were set in 1983 and 1993 and are not adjusted for inflation. As incomes and benefits rise over time, more retirees cross them.
What is the tax torpedo?
The tax torpedo is the income range where each extra dollar of other income also makes more of your Social Security taxable. In the 85% range, one more dollar of IRA income adds $1.85 to your taxable income: the dollar itself plus 85 cents of benefits.
That raises your effective tax rate on the extra dollar well above your bracket:
| Your bracket | Effective rate in the 50% range | Effective rate in the 85% range |
|---|---|---|
| 12% | 18% | 22.2% |
| 22% | 33% | 40.7% |
Once 85% of your benefit is already taxable, the torpedo ends. Each extra dollar is then taxed at your normal bracket rate, but 85% of your benefit stays in your taxable income every year.
Before: no conversions
| You | 62, single, retired; plan runs to age 92 |
|---|---|
| Accounts |
|
| Spending | $70,000 a year |
| Social Security | $40,000 a year, claimed at 70 |
| Tax law | 2025 federal law held constant, so every figure reads as today’s dollars |
| Returns and state tax | 5% a year on every account; flat 5% state income tax |
| Paying for things | Spending and conversion tax come from the taxable account first, then Roth, then the IRA |
Your RMDs start at 75. From 70 to 74, your IRA withdrawals for spending bring your AGI to about $74,000, and 75% of your benefit is taxable. At 75, RMDs begin, and from then on 85% of your benefit is taxable every year.
After: a Roth conversion plan
With the optimized plan, you convert $160,000 at 62, about $100,000 a year from 63 to 67 and $86,000 a year at 68 and 69. All of that happens before you claim Social Security, so none of it makes your benefit more taxable.
The plan converted a little more after you claimed: $30,000 a year from 70 to 72 and $16,000 a year at 73 and 74. Then your RMDs, about a third of the size they would have been, kept your income low.
| Your Social Security | No conversions | With conversions |
|---|---|---|
| Share of benefit taxable at 75 | 85% | 27% |
| Taxable Social Security at 75 | $34,000 | $10,900 |
| Share taxable at 92 | 85% | 66% |
| Lifetime taxable Social Security (of $920,000 in benefits) | $763,000 | $431,000 |
| Largest RMD | $128,000 | $40,000 |
| Federal income tax at 75 | $14,200 | $1,800 |
| Federal income tax at 92 | $31,500 | $5,900 |
| Lifetime federal income tax | $467,000 | $251,000 |
One caution: our model holds the $25,000 and $34,000 thresholds constant in today’s dollars. In reality they are fixed in nominal dollars, so inflation shrinks them every year. That means the model likely understates how much of your benefit would be taxed later, in both cases, and the real benefit of converting may be larger.
The twist: the best plan stays in the torpedo zone on purpose
With conversions, your income from 75 on sits inside the torpedo zone every year. Your AGI ranges from about $32,000 to $66,000, and the taxable share of your benefit is between 27% and 66%. The plan did not get you out of the zone. It moved you to the cheap end of it.
At that income, your top dollars fall in the 12% bracket in most years, so the torpedo rate is about 22%. Only at the very end, around 92, do they edge into the 22% bracket. Without conversions, 85% of your benefit is taxable and your top dollars fall in the 22% and then 24% brackets.
Getting out of the zone entirely would have meant converting nearly all of your IRA early, at higher rates, to bring your RMDs close to zero. The optimizer found that more expensive. The goal is the lowest lifetime tax, not zero taxable benefits.
When it works less well: if you are already claiming
Conversions tend to do less for Social Security taxes once benefits have started, because every converted dollar raises your provisional income in that year.
| You | 66, single, retired; plan runs to age 94 |
|---|---|
| Accounts |
|
| Spending | $60,000 a year |
| Social Security | $36,000 a year, already claiming |
| Tax law | 2025 federal law held constant, so every figure reads as today’s dollars |
| Returns and state tax | 5% a year on every account; flat 5% state income tax |
| Paying for things | Spending and conversion tax come from the taxable account first, then Roth, then the IRA |
Because you were born before 1960, your RMDs start at 73.
In our simulation, the plan converted $382,000: $90,000 at 66, about $31,000 a year from 67 to 72, and smaller amounts after. Here is what happened:
| Already claiming | No conversions | With conversions |
|---|---|---|
| Share of benefit taxable | About 1% at 66–69, rising to 85% from 78 | 85% at 66, about 68% most years after |
| Lifetime taxable Social Security | $688,000 | $712,000 |
| Lifetime RMDs | $1.28M | $710,000 |
| Lifetime federal income tax | $258,000 | $173,000 |
Your taxable Social Security went up slightly. Your lifetime federal income tax still fell by $85,000, because your RMDs were cut nearly in half. If you are already claiming, judge a conversion by its effect on your total tax, not on your taxable benefits alone.
How to cut Social Security taxes with Roth conversions
- Convert in the years before you claim. Conversions then raise your income without making any of your benefit taxable.
- Size conversions so your projected RMDs leave your provisional income low, ideally in the 10% or 12% bracket once Social Security starts.
- If you are already claiming, compare the torpedo rate on a conversion now with the rate your RMDs would face later.
- Plan to use Roth withdrawals for large expenses later. Qualified Roth withdrawals do not count in provisional income.
- Model your total lifetime tax, not just the taxable share of your benefits. Include Medicare premiums too, since conversions also raise the income Medicare looks at.
FAQ
Does a Roth conversion reduce my Social Security benefit?
No. A conversion does not change your benefit amount. It can change how much of the benefit is taxable in the conversion year, and it can raise Medicare premiums two years later.
Do Roth withdrawals count as income for Social Security taxes?
Qualified Roth IRA withdrawals do not. They are excluded from gross income, so they do not raise your provisional income.
Should I convert before or after claiming Social Security?
Before is often cheaper. Once benefits start, each converted dollar can make up to 85 cents more of your benefit taxable. After claiming, conversions can still lower your lifetime tax, as in the example above.
Does a Roth conversion count toward the Social Security earnings test?
No. The earnings test applies only to wages and self-employment income before full retirement age. IRA withdrawals, conversions, pensions, and investment income do not count.
At what age is Social Security no longer taxed?
There is no such age. Whether your benefit is taxable depends on your provisional income, not your age. The senior deduction available from 2025 through 2028 can lower your tax, but it does not change how much of your benefit is taxable.
Conclusion
Roth conversions cut Social Security taxes mainly by shrinking the RMDs that would otherwise push 85% of your benefit into taxable income. In our simulation, converting before you claimed cut your lifetime taxable benefits by $332,000 and your federal tax at 75 from $14,200 to $1,800.
The approach tends to work best when you have a large IRA and several years between retiring and claiming. For how to use those years, see our guide to the retirement tax valley. For the full set of strategies, see our Roth conversion strategy guide.
This article is for educational purposes and is not personalized tax or investment advice. Figures reflect 2025–2026 federal law as noted. Simulation results are illustrative and depend on the stated assumptions.