How to Avoid IRMAA Surcharges With Roth Conversions (and Lower Your Medicare Premiums)
IRMAA can add thousands a year to Medicare premiums. In our before-and-after simulation, Roth conversions turned 15 years of surcharges into 5 small ones.
Medicare’s income-related surcharges, known as IRMAA, often arrive years after you retire. The usual cause is not a big paycheck. It is required minimum distributions (RMDs) from a traditional IRA, which grow every year. If you want to know how to avoid IRMAA, the most effective time to act is usually before those RMDs start.
To show how this plays out, we ran one retiree through our simulation twice: once with no conversions and once with a Roth conversion plan.
This article explains how IRMAA works, why the two-year lookback creates a window before 63, and how to size conversions around the tier lines.
What is IRMAA?
IRMAA, the income-related monthly adjustment amount, is an extra charge added to your Medicare Part B and Part D premiums when your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) is above a set threshold. For IRMAA, MAGI is your adjusted gross income (AGI) plus tax-exempt interest. Social Security uses your tax return from two years earlier.
Here are the 2027 tiers for a single filer, based on 2025 income:
| 2025 MAGI (single) | Part B surcharge per month | Part D surcharge per month | Extra cost per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| $112,000 or less | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Over $112,000 to $141,000 | $83.70 | $15.40 | $1,189 |
| Over $141,000 to $177,000 | $209.40 | $39.70 | $2,989 |
| Over $177,000 to $212,000 | $335.00 | $64.00 | $4,788 |
| Over $212,000 to under $500,000 | $460.60 | $88.30 | $6,587 |
| $500,000 or more | $502.40 | $96.40 | $7,186 |
Source: CMS 2027 Medicare Parts B premiums and deductibles fact sheet. The standard Part B premium for 2027 is $209.40 a month. The thresholds below $500,000 are adjusted for inflation each year.
IRMAA tiers are cliffs. If your MAGI is $1 over a threshold, you pay the full surcharge for that tier.
Why RMDs are the real IRMAA trigger
RMDs are a rising percentage of your IRA balance: about 4.1% at 75, 6.3% at 85 and 9.3% at 92. With a large IRA, that rising percentage keeps pushing your income up long after you stop working.
In our simulation with no conversions, your MAGI is $103,000 at 75, just under the first tier line ($106,000 under 2025 rules). At 76 it reaches about $107,000, just over that line, which sets your premium at 78. From there it keeps climbing: $136,000 at 83, which moves you to the second tier at 85, and $180,000 at 92.
The two-year lookback and the age-63 window
Because of the lookback, your premiums at 65 depend on your income at 63. Income you earn or convert at 62 or earlier generally never affects a Medicare premium, as long as Medicare starts at 65. If your return from two years earlier is not yet on file, Social Security may use the year before and correct it later.
That makes the years before 63 especially valuable for conversions. In our simulation, the optimizer converted the most at 62: $160,000. In the brokerage example below, it converted about $200,000 a year at 60, 61, and 62.
From 63 on, every conversion counts toward a premium two years later, so the plan sized each year to a tier line.
Before and after: your $1.2M IRA
| You | 62, single, retired; plan runs to age 92 |
|---|---|
| Accounts |
|
| Spending | $70,000 a year |
| Social Security | $40,000 a year, claimed at 70 |
| Tax law | 2025 federal law held constant, so every figure reads as today’s dollars |
| Returns and state tax | 5% a year on every account; flat 5% state income tax |
| Paying for things | Spending and conversion tax come from the taxable account first, then Roth, then the IRA |
Your RMDs start at 75.
| Your Medicare surcharges | No conversions | With conversions |
|---|---|---|
| Years with a surcharge | 15 (ages 78–92) | 5 (ages 65–69) |
| Total surcharges | $30,100 | $5,300 |
| Largest yearly surcharge | $4,235 | $1,053 |
| Lifetime RMDs | $1.78M | $553,000 |
| Lifetime federal income tax | $467,000 | $251,000 |
The conversion schedule followed the tier lines:
| Age | Conversion | Your MAGI | Effect on Medicare |
|---|---|---|---|
| 62 | $160,000 | $200,000 | None: outside the lookback |
| 63–67 | about $100,000 a year | $133,000 | Top of the first tier: smallest surcharge at 65–69 |
| 68–69 | $86,000 | $106,000 | At the first threshold: no surcharge |
| 70 on | smaller, then none | $66,000 or less | No surcharge for life |
Why the plan accepted a small surcharge
The plan could have stayed under the first threshold every year. Instead, from 63 to 67 it converted up to the top of the first tier, paying about $1,053 a year in surcharges for 5 years.
Those larger conversions shrank your future RMDs enough to remove 15 later years of surcharges, including years at the second and third tiers. In this example, paying a small surcharge on purpose cost less than avoiding every surcharge each year.
What if you also have a large brokerage account?
| You | 60, single, retired; plan runs to age 92 |
|---|---|
| Accounts |
|
| Spending | $85,000 a year |
| Social Security | $36,000 a year, claimed at 67 |
| Tax law | 2025 federal law held constant, so every figure reads as today’s dollars |
| Returns and state tax | 5% a year on every account; flat 5% state income tax |
| Paying for things | Spending and conversion tax come from the taxable account first, then Roth, then the IRA |
With no conversions, your MAGI is $135,000 at 75 and $239,000 by 92, and you pay surcharges for 16 years, from 77 to 92, totaling $63,000 and reaching $5,826 a year.
With conversions, the plan converted about $200,000 a year at 60 to 62, before the lookback, then about $127,000 a year at 63 to 65, holding your MAGI at $200,000. It finished at 66.
You paid a third-tier surcharge of $4,235 a year at 65 to 67, totaling $13,000, and none after that. In this example, the conversion tax was paid from the brokerage account.
When you cannot avoid IRMAA entirely: a $2.2M IRA
A very large IRA changes the goal.
| You | 63, single, retired; plan runs to age 92 |
|---|---|
| Accounts |
|
| Spending | $90,000 a year |
| Social Security | $45,000 a year, claimed at 70 |
| Tax law | 2025 federal law held constant, so every figure reads as today’s dollars |
| Returns and state tax | 5% a year on every account; flat 5% state income tax |
| Paying for things | Spending and conversion tax come from the taxable account first, then Roth, then the IRA |
| $2.2M IRA | No conversions | With conversions |
|---|---|---|
| Years with a surcharge | 25 (ages 68–92) | 25 of 28 Medicare years |
| Total surcharges | $87,000 | $57,000 |
| Largest yearly surcharge | $5,826 | $4,235 |
| AGI at 85–92 | $228,000–$286,000 | mostly $133,000–$200,000 |
You still paid surcharges in most years, but at lower tiers, and $30,000 less in total. With an IRA this size, the realistic goal is a lower tier, not zero. Converting enough to get under every threshold would have meant very high tax brackets for several years.
How to avoid IRMAA with Roth conversions
- Map your MAGI for every year from 63 on, including projected RMDs from your current IRA balance.
- Convert as much as makes sense before 63, when conversions cannot affect a premium.
- From 63 on, size each conversion to stay just under a tier line. Because tiers are cliffs, leave a small cushion for unexpected income such as fund distributions.
- Accept a small surcharge in a few years if it removes larger ones later.
- After 65, use Roth withdrawals for large expenses. Qualified Roth withdrawals do not count in MAGI.
- If your income dropped because you stopped or cut back work, file Form SSA-44 to ask Social Security to use your current income instead.
Other ways to lower Medicare premiums
- Qualified charitable distributions (QCDs). From 70½, IRA money sent directly to charity is excluded from AGI, so it does not count toward IRMAA. The limit is $111,000 in 2026.
- Timing capital gains. Large sales can push you over a tier for one year; spreading them out may help.
- Watch tax-exempt interest. Municipal bond interest is not taxed, but it does count in IRMAA MAGI.
- Appeal after a life-changing event. Form SSA-44 covers events such as marriage, divorce, a spouse’s death, work stoppage or reduction, and loss of pension income. A Roth conversion is not one of them.
FAQ
Does a Roth conversion increase my Medicare premiums?
It can. A conversion raises your MAGI in the year you make it, which can raise your premiums two years later. Conversions at 62 or earlier do not affect premiums that start at 65.
What year’s income does IRMAA use?
Usually your tax return from two years before the premium year. Your 2027 premiums are based on your 2025 income.
Do Roth IRA withdrawals count toward IRMAA?
Qualified Roth withdrawals do not. They are not part of AGI, so they do not raise your MAGI.
Can I appeal IRMAA?
Yes, if your income dropped because of a qualifying life-changing event, using Form SSA-44. You can also request a new determination if the tax information Social Security used was wrong or out of date.
Is IRMAA based on AGI or MAGI?
MAGI. For IRMAA, that is your AGI plus tax-exempt interest.
Conclusion
RMDs are what push many retirees into IRMAA for life. In our simulation, converting before 63 and sizing later conversions to the tier lines turned 15 years of surcharges into 5 small ones, and in the brokerage example 16 years into 3. With a $2.2 million IRA, surcharges remained, but at lower tiers.
This approach tends to fit best when your IRA is large enough to create big RMDs but small enough to convert down before RMDs begin. For how conversions shrink RMDs, see our RMD guide. For how the same RMDs affect your Social Security taxes, see our tax torpedo guide. For the full set of strategies, see our Roth conversion strategy guide.
This article is for educational purposes and is not personalized tax or investment advice. Figures reflect 2025–2027 federal law and Medicare rules as noted. Simulation results are illustrative and depend on the stated assumptions.