How to Pay Taxes on a Roth Conversion (and Shrink Your Taxable Account)
Paying Roth conversion tax from a brokerage account moves more money into the Roth. In our simulation, it cut taxable investment income by $750,000.
There are three ways to pay taxes on a Roth conversion: have tax withheld from the conversion, withdraw extra from the IRA to cover the bill, or pay from savings outside the IRA, such as a brokerage account. You send the payment through estimated taxes or extra withholding on other income. If you can afford it, paying from outside savings is often the stronger choice.
Where the money comes from matters almost as much as how much you convert. To show how much, we ran one household through our simulation twice: once with no conversions and once converting and paying the tax from a brokerage account.
This article compares the three ways to pay, shows the math, and explains the trade-off: selling shares to pay the tax realizes capital gains.
Three ways to pay the tax on a Roth conversion
| How you pay | How much reaches the Roth | Penalty risk under 59½ | Long-run effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Withhold from the conversion | Less than you convert; the withheld amount is a regular distribution | The withheld amount can face the 10% additional tax | Smallest Roth |
| Withdraw extra from the IRA to pay | All of the converted amount, but more leaves the IRA | The extra withdrawal can face the 10% additional tax | Same as withholding, in a different form |
| Pay from taxable savings | All of it | None from the payment itself | Largest Roth; smaller taxable account |
IRA distributions have 10% federal withholding by default unless you elect otherwise on Form W-4R. If you plan to pay from other savings, you can elect no withholding on the conversion.
Should you pay Roth conversion taxes from the IRA or from other savings?
From other savings, if you can. Every dollar of tax you pay from a brokerage account is a dollar that stays in the IRA and moves into the Roth, where it grows tax-free. In effect, it works like an extra Roth contribution with no annual limit, funded from an account whose income is taxed every year.
The math: a $100,000 conversion
Say you convert $100,000 and the tax is $22,000. Here is how each choice looks after 20 years at 5% a year.
| Pay from the IRA | Pay from a brokerage account | |
|---|---|---|
| Lands in the Roth | $78,000 | $100,000 |
| Brokerage account change | none | −$22,000 |
| Roth after 20 years | $207,000 | $265,300 |
| What the $22,000 would have grown to in the brokerage account, before taxes | $58,400 | — |
Simplified: 5% a year compounded; ignores state tax and the 10% penalty if you are under 59½.
If the brokerage account were never taxed, the two choices would come out about even: $207,000 plus $58,400 is roughly $265,300. The difference comes from taxes on the brokerage account along the way.
For example, if the account yields 2.2% a year in dividends and interest, taxed at an average rate of 15%, the $22,000 grows to about $54,800 instead of $58,400, before any tax on gains when you sell. Paying from the brokerage account comes out about $3,600 ahead per $100,000 converted. That edge grows with a higher yield, a higher tax rate, more years, or a bigger account. If you are under 59½, avoiding the 10% penalty on the $22,000 adds $2,200 more.
Tax drag: what a brokerage account costs you every year
A brokerage account is taxed while you own it. Interest and dividends are taxable every year, and selling shares can realize capital gains. A Roth IRA has none of that.
In our simulation with no conversions, your required minimum distributions (RMDs) start at 75, and you do not need most of them to cover spending. They get reinvested, and your brokerage account grows to $3.28 million by 92. At that point it produces $68,000 a year of taxable interest and dividends on top of an RMD of $140,000.
Before and after: paying from your brokerage account
| You | 60, single, retired; plan runs to age 92 |
|---|---|
| Accounts |
|
| Spending | $85,000 a year |
| Social Security | $36,000 a year, claimed at 67 |
| Tax law | 2025 federal law held constant, so every figure reads as today’s dollars |
| Returns and state tax | 5% a year on every account; flat 5% state income tax |
| Paying for things | Spending and conversion tax come from the taxable account first, then Roth, then the IRA |
| Lifetime, age 60 to 92 | No conversions | With conversions |
|---|---|---|
| Converted to Roth | $0 | $1.0M (ages 60–66) |
| Taxable dividends and interest | $1.21M | $462,000 |
| Capital gains realized | $450,000 | $1.03M |
| RMDs | $1.96M | $0 |
| Medicare surcharges (IRMAA) | $63,000 over 16 years | $13,000 over 3 years |
| Net investment income tax | $5,000 | $9,000 |
| Federal income tax | $614,000 | $300,000 |
| State income tax | $221,000 | $154,000 |
| Accounts at 92 | $1.44M IRA + $3.28M brokerage | $4.49M Roth |
Why a smaller total can be worth more
With conversions, your accounts at 92 add up to $4.49 million instead of $4.72 million. That looks like a loss of $230,000. But the two totals are not taxed the same way.
The $1.44 million left in the IRA is still taxable when it comes out. If your heirs pay 32% on it, they keep about $979,000. Add the brokerage account, and they receive about $4.26 million without conversions, compared with $4.49 million from the Roth.
Our comparison counts the brokerage account at full value, as if your heirs inherit it with a stepped-up basis and owe no tax on its gains. That gives the brokerage account its best case. The lesson: compare after-tax value, not account totals.
The trade-off: realizing capital gains
Paying the tax from a brokerage account means selling shares, and selling appreciated shares realizes gains. In our simulation, you realized $1.03 million of capital gains with conversions, compared with $450,000 without.
The conversion years also pushed your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) above $200,000, the threshold for the 3.8% net investment income tax, from 60 to 62. Your lifetime net investment income tax rose from $5,000 to $9,000.
Our model sells shares in proportion to what you hold. In practice, you may be able to realize less gain:
- Spend cash and bond holdings first.
- Sell the lots with the highest cost basis first.
- Harvest losses to offset gains.
- Time larger sales for years when your income is lower.
Keeping the brokerage account intact can make more sense if your shares have very low basis and you expect your heirs to inherit them soon, since the step-up in basis would erase those gains.
Why the plan front-loaded your conversions
The optimizer converted large amounts early and finished by 66.
| Ages | Conversion each year | Your AGI | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| 60–62 | about $198,000 | about $282,000 | Fills the 24% bracket (2025 law); income before 63 never sets a Medicare premium |
| 63–65 | about $127,000 | $200,000 | Stops at the net investment income tax threshold, which is also the top of the third IRMAA tier (2025) |
| 66 | $24,000 | $85,000 | Empties the IRA before Social Security starts at 67 |
At 60 to 62, the conversion filled the ordinary-income brackets up to the top of 24%. The capital gains and dividends from selling shares were added on top and taxed at capital gains rates, which is why your adjusted gross income (AGI) reached about $282,000.
Finishing early meant no RMDs at all and kept conversions from making your Social Security more taxable. Your lifetime taxable Social Security fell from $796,000 to $584,000.
How to pay the tax on a Roth conversion, step by step
- Decide the conversion amount late in the year, once your other income is known. A conversion cannot be undone.
- Choose what to sell to raise the tax money: cash first, then the highest-basis lots.
- Pay the tax with an estimated payment on Form 1040-ES, or increase withholding on other income such as a pension or Social Security. Withholding is treated as paid evenly through the year, which can help with a conversion made in December.
- Check the safe harbor. You generally avoid an underpayment penalty if your payments cover 100% of last year’s tax (110% if last year’s AGI was over $150,000) or 90% of this year’s. For a late-year conversion, the annualized income method on Form 2210 may also reduce a penalty.
- Report the conversion on Form 8606 and keep records of what you sold and its basis.
When paying from the IRA may be fine
- You have no taxable savings, or need them as an emergency fund.
- You are over 59½ and a conversion still makes sense at a lower rate, even with a smaller amount reaching the Roth.
- Your only taxable assets are very low-basis shares you expect to leave to heirs soon.
Also check your health coverage. If you buy insurance through the ACA marketplace before 65, conversion income can reduce or eliminate your premium tax credit. Our model does not include ACA credits.
FAQ
Can I pay the conversion tax from the IRA?
Yes, through withholding or an extra withdrawal. Less money reaches the Roth, and if you are under 59½, the amount used for tax can face the 10% additional tax.
Should I withhold taxes from a Roth conversion?
Usually not, if you can pay from other savings. If you do withhold, the withheld amount is not converted, and your Roth starts smaller.
Do I need to pay estimated taxes on a conversion?
Often, yes, unless your withholding or prior payments already meet the safe harbor. A conversion can add a large amount of income in one year, so check before the next estimated-tax due date.
Does selling stock to pay the tax make the conversion worse?
It adds a cost, depending on your situation: capital gains tax on the shares you sell, and possibly the net investment income tax. In our simulation, the conversions still cut lifetime federal income tax by $314,000 even after realizing $580,000 more in gains. Choosing high-basis lots can reduce that cost.
Conclusion
How you pay the tax on a Roth conversion shapes how much good the conversion does. Paying from a brokerage account moves more money into the Roth and shrinks an account that is taxed every year. In our simulation, it cut your taxable dividends and interest by about $750,000 and left your heirs more after tax, even with a smaller total balance.
This approach tends to fit people with a sizable brokerage account and a large pre-tax IRA, early in retirement. The years you convert also raise your income for Medicare’s lookback, so plan them with IRMAA in mind. For when to convert, see our guide to the retirement tax valley. For the full set of strategies, see our Roth conversion strategy guide.
This article is for educational purposes and is not personalized tax or investment advice. Figures reflect 2025–2026 federal law as noted. Simulation results are illustrative and depend on the stated assumptions.