When to Do a Roth Conversion: How to Use the Retirement Tax Valley
The years between retiring and RMDs are often your lowest-tax years. See how a $1.2M IRA saver used them to cut lifetime federal tax by $216,000.
For many people, the lowest-tax years of their adult life come right after they stop working. The paychecks end, Social Security has not started, and required minimum distributions (RMDs) are still years away. If you are wondering when to do a Roth conversion, those years are usually the first place to look.
To show what those years can be worth, we ran one retiree through our simulation twice: once with no conversions and once using the valley for Roth conversions.
This article explains what the retirement tax valley is, how to size conversions to fill it, and why the right amount changes from year to year.
What is the retirement tax valley?
The retirement tax valley is the stretch of low-income years between retirement and the start of Social Security and RMDs. Income drops when work ends, then rises again when those income sources begin.
Because the U.S. income tax is progressive, the first dollars of income each year are taxed at low rates. In the valley, those low brackets often go unused.
Here is the household we simulated:
| You | 62, single, retired; plan runs to age 92 |
|---|---|
| Accounts |
|
| Spending | $70,000 a year |
| Social Security | $40,000 a year, claimed at 70 |
| Tax law | 2025 federal law held constant, so every figure reads as today’s dollars |
| Returns and state tax | 5% a year on every account; flat 5% state income tax |
| Paying for things | Spending and conversion tax come from the taxable account first, then Roth, then the IRA |
With no conversions, your adjusted gross income (AGI) follows the valley:
| Your age | AGI with no conversions | What is happening |
|---|---|---|
| 62–65 | about $27,000 | Living on taxable savings; federal tax $0 |
| 66 | $17,000 | Taxable savings run out |
| 67–69 | $41,000–$88,000 | Spending now comes from the Roth, then the IRA |
| 70–74 | $74,000 | Social Security begins at 70 |
| 75 | $103,000 | First RMD |
| 92 | $180,000 | RMDs keep growing |
In this way, the valley is temporary. The longer you wait, the more of your IRA will eventually be taxed on top of Social Security and RMDs, often in higher brackets.
When should you do a Roth conversion?
For many retirees, the best time to do a Roth conversion is after paychecks stop and before Social Security, RMDs, and Medicare premiums take effect. Those are the years when your taxable income is lowest, so each converted dollar is taxed at a lower rate than it likely would be later.
Other times can also make sense:
- A market decline. The same tax buys more shares, and the rebound happens inside the Roth.
- A year with unusually large deductions, such as big medical expenses.
- A year with a gap in income, such as a sabbatical or a break between jobs.
Timing within the year matters too. A conversion counts in the year it happens, and it cannot be undone. Many people wait until late in the year, when they know their other income, before deciding how much to convert.
How much should you convert? Use thresholds, not round numbers
Converting “$50,000 a year” is easy to remember, but it rarely matches the tax code. A better approach is to convert up to, or just under, a specific threshold. The table shows the ones that matter most for a single filer, expressed as AGI where possible.
| Threshold (single filer) | 2026 | 2027 | What crossing it costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Top of the 12% bracket (taxable income) | $50,400 | $52,025 | Next dollar taxed at 22% instead of 12% |
| Top of the 12% bracket as AGI, under 65 (bracket top plus standard deduction) | $66,500 | $68,625 | Same |
| Top of the 22% bracket (taxable income) | $105,700 | $109,125 | Next dollar taxed at 24% |
| Top of the 24% bracket (taxable income) | $201,775 | $208,325 | Next dollar taxed at 32% |
| 0% long-term capital gains ceiling (taxable income) | $49,450 | not yet confirmed | Gains above it taxed at 15% |
| First Medicare IRMAA tier (MAGI, two years before the premium year) | $112,000 for 2027 premiums | — | Full tier surcharge; it is a cliff |
| Net investment income tax (MAGI) | $200,000 | $200,000 | 3.8% on investment income above it |
Sources: IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32 and 2026-35; CMS 2027 premium fact sheet; IRC §1411.
Two kinds of thresholds behave differently:
- Bracket tops are “fill up to” lines. Going $1 over only taxes that dollar at the next rate.
- IRMAA tiers are cliffs. Going $1 over adds the full surcharge for that tier, so they are “stay under” lines.
If you are 65 or older, your thresholds in AGI terms are higher. You get an additional standard deduction ($2,050 for a single filer in 2026) and, from 2025 through 2028, a senior deduction of up to $6,000 that phases out at 6% of income above $75,000.
Worked example: your conversion schedule
Here is the conversion schedule the optimizer chose for you, and the threshold each amount was aimed at. Our simulation uses 2025 law held constant, so the threshold amounts are 2025 figures.
| Age | Conversion | Your AGI | Why this amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| 62 | $160,000 | $200,000 | Income at 62 never sets a Medicare premium, so the plan converted the most here |
| 63–67 | about $100,000 a year | $133,000 | Top of the first IRMAA tier (2025): pay the smallest surcharge, not a larger one |
| 68–69 | $86,000 | $106,000 | Just under the first IRMAA threshold (2025): no surcharge |
| 70–72 | $30,000 | $64,000 | Top of the 12% bracket once Social Security starts |
| 73–74 | $16,000 | $28,000 | Small top-ups before RMDs |
| 75 on | none | $32,000–$66,000 | RMDs are now small enough to stay in low brackets |
In total, you converted $965,000. Your lifetime federal income tax fell from $467,000 to $251,000, and your largest RMD fell from $128,000 to $40,000.
Notice what the plan did not do. It did not convert everything at once, and it did not stop at the 12% bracket in the valley.
Before Social Security, the optimizer judged that paying 22% or 24% on conversions now was cheaper than the alternative: similar or higher rates on RMDs later, plus the Medicare surcharges and Social Security taxation those RMDs would trigger.
Why a single rule of thumb leaves money on the table
We also tested common rules of thumb on the same household. Each one helped, but none matched the plan that changed with your situation.
| Approach | Gain vs no conversions |
|---|---|
| Optimized schedule (above) | +$311,000 |
| Stay under the first IRMAA tier every year | +$229,000 |
| Fill the 12% bracket every year | +$204,000 |
| Fill the 22% bracket every year | +$190,000 |
Gain is measured as ending after-tax value, with the remaining traditional IRA reduced by 24% federal and 5% state tax.
The reason is that the right target moves. Before 63, Medicare premiums are not affected. From 63, IRMAA tiers start to matter. At 70, Social Security adds income, and each extra dollar of other income can make up to 85 cents more of your benefit taxable. At 75, RMDs take over. A rule that ignores those changes converts too little in some years and too much in others.
What can close the valley early or change the math
Your valley may be wider, narrower, or more expensive than the one in our example. Common reasons include:
- Social Security timing. Claiming at 62 shrinks the valley, because benefits add income and conversions can make more of them taxable. Delaying to 70, as in our example, widens it.
- ACA health insurance before 65. Conversions raise the income used for premium tax credits. With the enhanced credits expired after 2025, income above 400% of the federal poverty level can cost the entire credit, so the cliff may matter more than any bracket.
- Part-time work, consulting income, or a pension.
- Selling a home or a business, which can fill a year with income.
- Large medical or long-term care expenses, which can create deductions.
- The 65+ deductions mentioned above, which our model does not include.
How to pay the tax on a conversion
Where the tax money comes from matters. Paying from a taxable brokerage account lets the full conversion reach the Roth. Having tax withheld from the conversion means less reaches the Roth, and if you are under 59½ the withheld amount may also face a 10% penalty.
You can pay through estimated tax payments or by increasing withholding on other income. Withholding is treated as paid evenly through the year, which can help with a conversion made in December. More in our guide to paying the tax on a Roth conversion.
Step by step: planning your valley conversions
- Map your expected income for every year from now until at least 75: pensions, Social Security, withdrawals, and investment income.
- Project your RMDs from your current IRA balance, growth, and the IRS Uniform Lifetime Table.
- Pick a threshold for each year: a bracket top before Medicare, an IRMAA tier from 63 on, the top of a low bracket once Social Security starts.
- Convert late in the year, once your other income for the year is known.
- Pay the tax from taxable savings, and check that your estimated payments meet the safe harbor (100% of last year’s tax, or 110% if last year’s AGI was over $150,000).
- Revisit the plan every year, since tax law, markets, and your spending will change.
FAQ
Should I convert my IRA to a Roth after 60?
It can make sense, especially if you have stopped working and have several years before Social Security and RMDs. Those are often your lowest-tax years. Converting after 59½ also avoids the 10% penalty if you ever need to pay part of the tax from the IRA.
Is it better to convert in one year or spread it out?
Spreading it out usually costs less, because each year’s conversion is taxed starting from the bottom brackets. In our simulation, the optimizer never converted everything in one year.
Should I convert before or after claiming Social Security?
Before claiming is often cheaper. Once benefits start, conversion income can make more of your benefit taxable, which raises the effective rate on each converted dollar.
Does a Roth conversion affect my ACA subsidy?
Yes. A conversion raises the modified AGI used to calculate premium tax credits, so it can reduce or eliminate your subsidy for that year.
What if the market drops after I convert?
You still owe tax on the value at the time of the conversion, and conversions can no longer be undone. Converting late in the year, or in several smaller pieces, reduces the chance of regret.
Conclusion
The retirement tax valley is temporary. Social Security narrows it, and RMDs end it. Using those years to convert, in amounts sized to real thresholds, lowered lifetime federal tax by $216,000 in our example.
Whether it fits your plan depends on how many low-income years you have, how you would pay the tax, and what your health coverage costs before 65. For the bigger picture, see our guide to Roth conversion strategy.
This article is for educational purposes and is not personalized tax or investment advice. Figures reflect 2025–2027 federal law as noted. Simulation results are illustrative and depend on the stated assumptions.