Comparing HSA Plans to Silver and Gold Plans
A high-deductible plan with an HSA versus silver and gold plans: how the tax savings and employer contributions change which plan costs least, with a calculator for your own plans.
When choosing a health plan, most people compare two numbers: the monthly premium and the deductible. A high-deductible health plan (HDHP) usually has the lowest premium and the highest deductible. Silver and gold plans, or the medium- and low-deductible plans offered by many employers, cost more each month but begin paying for care sooner.
This leads to a common rule of thumb: choose the high-deductible plan if you are healthy, and choose the gold plan if you expect medical bills.
While this rule is simple, it leaves out the Health Savings Account (HSA). An HDHP is the only kind of plan that allows you to contribute to an HSA. For 2027, you can contribute up to $4,500 with self-only coverage or $9,000 with family coverage, and that money is never subject to federal income tax if it is spent on qualified medical expenses.
This article builds the comparison one step at a time and shows how the HSA changes it. The numbers come from an example, but every table and chart below is also a calculator. Replace the example with your own plans, and the figures throughout the article will update.
The Three Plans
Here is how three example plans for self-only coverage compare:
The deductible is the amount of medical bills you pay in full before the plan begins to pay. After the deductible, you pay only the coinsurance percentage of each bill. Once your spending reaches the out-of-pocket maximum, the plan pays 100%.
Silver and gold are marketplace terms. If your plans come from an employer, the silver plan here stands in for the medium-deductible option and the gold plan for the low-deductible option. On the marketplace, every bronze plan has been HSA-eligible since 2026.
How the Cost of a Plan Is Calculated
The cost of a health plan for the year has two parts. Premiums are owed no matter what happens. Out-of-pocket costs depend on your medical bills.
Out-of-pocket costs can be calculated as follows:
If Medical Bills are less than the Deductible
Out-of-Pocket = Medical Bills
If Medical Bills are greater than the Deductible
Out-of-Pocket = Deductible + (Medical Bills – Deductible) * Coinsurance
Remember though, your out-of-pocket costs can be at most the out-of-pocket maximum.
This makes the cost of a plan, before considering the HSA:
Total Cost = Annual Premiums + Out-of-Pocket
The chart below shows this total cost for each plan at every level of medical bills. The lowest line is the least expensive plan.
This is the comparison behind the rule of thumb. The plan with the lowest premium is usually the least expensive when medical bills are low, and the plans with lower deductibles take over as the bills rise.
What the HSA Adds
The HSA changes this comparison in two ways.
1) Tax Savings
HSA contributions are not subject to federal income tax. Most states do not tax them either, with California and New Jersey being the exceptions. Additionally, if you contribute through your employer’s payroll, the contribution also avoids the 7.65% Social Security and Medicare tax.
HSA Tax Savings = HSA Contribution * (Federal Rate + State Rate + 7.65% if through payroll)
These savings do not depend on your health. They are the same in a year with no medical bills as in a year with $50,000 of them. However, you only receive them if you actually make the contribution.
2) Employer Contributions
Many employers deposit money into the HSA of each employee who chooses the high-deductible plan. Every dollar deposited reduces the cost of that plan by a dollar. Employer contributions count toward the annual limit.
This makes the full calculation:
Net Cost = Annual Premiums + Out-of-Pocket – HSA Tax Savings – Employer HSA Contribution
The HSA does not change the shape of the high-deductible plan’s line. It moves the entire line down by the same amount, $1,334 in this case, at every level of medical bills. The dashed line shows where it was before.
For marketplace plans, there is one more effect that this calculation does not include. An HSA contribution lowers the income used to determine your premium tax credit. Since households above 400% of the federal poverty level receive no credit in 2027, a contribution that brings your income under that line can be worth much more than the tax savings alone.
Examples
To make this more concrete, here are three examples using the plans and tax rates entered above.
Example 1 ($1,000 of medical bills)
Example 2 ($5,000 of medical bills)
Example 3 ($20,000 of medical bills)
The premiums and the HSA savings are the same in all three examples. Only the out-of-pocket costs change.
The Worst Case
High-deductible plans are often seen as the risky choice because of their larger out-of-pocket maximum. The same calculation shows how much risk there is. In the worst year, each plan costs its premiums plus its out-of-pocket maximum, minus any HSA savings.
Once the lower premiums and the HSA savings are subtracted, the worst case for the high-deductible plan is often close to the worst case for the other plans. In some cases it is lower.
Investing the HSA
The calculation so far only counts this year’s tax savings. HSA balances can also be invested, and the growth is not taxed if it is eventually spent on qualified medical expenses.
If you can pay this year’s medical bills from other savings and leave the HSA invested, the contribution is worth more than its initial tax savings. Compared to investing the after-tax amount in a regular brokerage account for 20 years at a 6% return, with the gains taxed at 15%, this year’s contribution is worth about $1,831 today, rather than $1,334.
When Silver or Gold Is the Better Choice
There are situations where the high-deductible plan is not the best fit, even after counting the HSA.
First, the HSA only has value if you fund it. If you would not make the contribution, the first chart in this article is your comparison, not the second.
Second, if your medical bills reliably land in a range where another plan has the lowest line, that plan costs less. Recurring prescriptions and planned procedures make your bills more predictable than most.
Third, marketplace buyers with household income up to 250% of the federal poverty level qualify for cost-sharing reductions. These lower the deductible and out-of-pocket maximum, but only on silver plans.
Fourth, the higher deductible has to be paid from somewhere. If a large bill early in the year would end up on a credit card, the interest can outweigh the savings.
Finally, the calculation assumes the plans differ only in cost. Compare the provider networks and drug coverage as well. If the silver or gold plan is paired with a Flexible Spending Account (FSA), that account provides a similar tax break on a smaller amount, although the money must generally be spent in the same year. Also, you cannot contribute to an HSA once you are enrolled in Medicare.
Conclusion
Silver and gold plans are easy to understand. You pay more each month, and you pay less when you need care.
However, comparing premiums and deductibles alone leaves out the HSA. The tax savings and any employer contribution lower the cost of the high-deductible plan at every level of medical bills, which often makes it the least expensive plan in far more situations than the rule of thumb suggests.
If you are deciding between plans, enter their numbers in the table above and compare the lines for your own situation.
The calculator models the deductible, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket maximum. It does not model copays, services covered before the deductible, per-person family deductibles, or out-of-network care. The 7.65% payroll tax savings drops to 1.45% on wages above the Social Security wage base. This article is educational and is not personalized tax or insurance advice.